ND Morris logo
White papers

In Search of the Aha Moment: Or When a CEO Refuses to Be Accountable

By Nik Morris ·

Share this paperLinkedInXFacebookEmail

I am the person holding my company back.

That's a hard sentence to say out loud, and it's the sentence this paper is about. So I'll start with my own version of it.

Not long ago, I invited a CEO to sit in at a small table of peers. As the questions got sharper, I didn't step in, and the group ended up badgering him. As the chair, that was mine to stop, and I didn't. I own it. I've also forgiven myself for it, publicly, here, because leaders who can't forgive their own mistakes rarely admit the next one. I've changed how I run the room, and I'm moving on.

What stayed with me wasn't my mistake. It was his reaction, and what it showed me about how an aha moment does or doesn't happen.

In brief

Every company I've watched get unstuck had the same turning point. The person at the top said, in his or her own words, some version of "I am the person holding my company back." That's the aha moment. It can't be handed to a CEO, and it can't be pushed into one.

This paper is for two kinds of readers. If you're a CEO, it's about the conversation that gets you to your own aha, and the three truths underneath it. If you work under or around a CEO who refuses to have that moment, it's about recognizing the pattern, protecting yourself and building a career that doesn't wait on his breakthrough.

Three truths about growth

Everything I've learned about the aha moment comes back to three truths.

The only way you grow is to step into the space where you're uncomfortable. Comfort is where you already know the answers. If a conversation about your business never makes you squirm, it isn't touching anything that needs to change. The discomfort isn't a sign the conversation went wrong. It's usually the sign it's finally going somewhere.

The only way you grow is to have people who can see your blind spots. You're so deep in the weeds of your own company that you'll never see them yourself. That isn't a character flaw. It's what happens when you're the one doing the work, making the calls and carrying the history. The people around you, your team, your peers and your advisors, can see what you can't. But only if you let them say it, and only if you listen when they do.

You have to be open enough to pause and say, "aha." The first two truths bring you to the edge. This one is the step. When someone shows you something uncomfortable about yourself, there's a beat where you choose between defending and considering. The aha lives in that pause. It sounds like "Huh. That's me, isn't it?" instead of "That's not fair."

Miss any one of the three, and the aha doesn't come. Here's what that looks like.

A case study: the CEO who already knew

Here's the story, with names and identifying details left out.

He runs a CPA and tax firm of about $1 million. He hates the tax work and says so openly. But he won't let go of it, because, in his words, it keeps the lights on. What he wants to be doing is financial advisory, and that side of the business brings in about $30,000. So the firm sits in between: a business he doesn't want, keeping alive a business he hasn't built.

There are no SOPs. Nothing is written down. The way work gets done lives in his head, and it's his way.

He has a long-tenured number two. She does the work, but she has no customer-facing role at all. So she carries the load without the visibility or customer relationships that would let her grow, or ever replace him. He hasn't developed her, taught her how he thinks or hired anyone to take load off her. And when things fall through the cracks, he blames her for gaps he created.

When the table asked him hard questions, he answered with personal ones aimed at the people asking. When members sent thoughtful follow-up notes, his reply was, "I already knew that." When he was told he hadn't been voted in, he blamed everyone else in the room.

None of this was new to him. He'd had this same level of conversation several times before, about owning his behavior, about the control and about how he treats his number two, and nothing had changed. This isn't a one-time lapse. It's an entrenched pattern.

One member read him as narcissistic. That's that member's read, not a diagnosis, and I'm not qualified to make one. You don't need a label to see what happened. Look at it through the three truths.

He wouldn't step into the uncomfortable space. The tax work he hates is comfortable because it's known. The advisory work he wants is uncomfortable because it's not, so it stays at $30,000.

He wouldn't let anyone see his blind spots. The people at that table could see in an hour what he couldn't see in years. When they named it, he turned the questions back on them.

And he couldn't pause. "I already knew that" is the opposite of "aha." It closes the door at exactly the moment it could have opened.

The conversation that leads to the aha

You can't force anyone's aha moment. Our table tried, and the harder we pushed, the harder he defended the very thing holding him back. Pressure produces defense, not insight. A CEO who is told, "You're the bottleneck," hears a verdict. A CEO who notices on his own, "Every decision this month waited on me," has found a fact.

What you can do is make the conversation one where the aha is more likely. These three levers do that. Each one works for the people around a CEO, and each one works just as well when a CEO uses it on himself or herself.

Frame the conversation around ownership

If you're around the CEO: before a hard conversation, say what it's for, and go first. In a 1:1: "I want to look at what's in my control and what's in yours, and I'll start with mine." In a leadership meeting: "Can we spend ten minutes on what each of us owns in this miss before we talk about fixes?"

If you're the CEO: say it to your team before they say anything to you. "I want to hear what I'm doing that's making this harder. Nobody gets in trouble for telling me." Then mean it.

Going first makes admitting something normal instead of dangerous. A study published in Administrative Science Quarterly (1999) looked at 51 work teams in a manufacturing company. It described psychological safety as "a shared belief held by members of a team that the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking," and found that teams with more of it engaged in more learning behavior, which in turn was linked to better team performance. That's the second truth in research form. People only show you your blind spots when it feels safe to.

Name a deflection once, calmly, then move on

If you're around the CEO: when a question about the business turns into a question about you, name it once: "I think we've moved off the customer issue. Can we come back to it?" Then go back to the topic. No speech, no second round. Naming it shows you saw it. Moving on lets him come back without losing face.

If you're the CEO: catch yourself. When someone raises something hard and you feel the urge to question them, their motives, their experience or their life, that urge is the signal. Name it to yourself: "I'm deflecting." Then go back to the question they actually asked.

Use the mirror question

If you're around the CEO: ask him to look at someone else's situation. "If another firm owner told you he hated half his business but kept it because it paid the bills, and nothing was written down, what would you tell him?" Then be quiet. A hypothetical can't be attacked, and if an answer comes, it's in his own words.

If you're the CEO: ask yourself the same question. Write one paragraph describing your company as if it belonged to another founder. Then write the advice you'd give that founder. Most of us give excellent advice to other people. Sometimes, halfway through writing it, you hear yourself. That's the pause. That's the aha.

If you work for a CEO who won't have the aha

Some of you reading this aren't the CEO. You're the number two, the operations lead or the person who quietly keeps the place running. You may recognize the CEO in the case study, because you work for someone like him.

Stop tying your growth to his self-awareness. He may have his aha next quarter. He may never have it. If he's had the same conversation several times without changing, believe the pattern. Hope for his aha. Don't build your future on it.

Protect yourself. Keep a simple record of what you were asked to do and what you delivered. Write SOPs for your own work, so "you should have known" has an answer. After conversations that matter, send a short note: "Here's what I heard we agreed on." When a business question turns personal, you don't have to answer it.

Build your own proof points. Track results with numbers: the deadlines you hit, the problems you solved, the work you took over and improved. In a company where the CEO takes the visible credit, this is how your work stays yours.

Build relationships he doesn't control. Customers, if you're allowed near them, your peers in the industry, vendors and partners who know your work, people in your field who've walked this road. They let you see your value from somewhere other than his desk, and they'll vouch for you later.

Learn what he won't teach. If he won't show you pricing, the numbers or how he makes decisions, learn it anyway. Read, take a course, ask a peer at another firm, find an advisor of your own.

Ask for one decision, not more work. Skip "I'd like more responsibility." He'll hear more tasks. Ask for one specific decision that becomes yours, with a clear line around it and a date to review how it went.

None of this is disloyal. And sometimes, when the person closest to a CEO starts growing on her own terms, that's what finally holds up the mirror he needed.

His ceiling doesn't have to become yours.

Stay or go

At some point the question becomes "Should I still be here?" Decide it on purpose, not on your worst day. Privately, pick a window and what you need to see by the end of it.

Stay if he's handed you at least one real decision and let it stand, if your documented work is being used, and if you're still learning and still believe in the work.

Go if your record keeps getting rewritten in his version of events, if you've asked for one defined decision and been refused more than once, or if your health and home life are paying for the job.

If you go, leave well. Hand over your SOPs and your open work properly, and keep your reputation as the person who left things better. Your record and your relationships go with you.

The wrong answer is waiting for his aha and calling it a plan.

An honest self-check

If you're the CEO. Yes, partly or no.

  1. In the last month, have you stepped into a conversation or decision that made you uncomfortable?
  2. Do you have people who will tell you your blind spots, and have they done it recently?
  3. When you heard something hard, did you pause, or did you explain why it wasn't true?
  4. Is there someone on your team carrying the load without the visibility to grow?
  5. Could you say, "I am the person holding my company back," and mean it about something specific?

If you work around one. Yes, partly or no.

  1. Could you list three results you drove this year, with numbers?
  2. Is your own work written down well enough for someone else to follow?
  3. Do you have relationships in your field that don't run through your CEO?
  4. Do you know your own stay-or-go timeline?
  5. If he never has his aha moment, do you still have a plan?

Every "no" or "partly" is a place where the aha, his or yours, is still waiting.

Your Monday move

If you're the CEO: write the mirror paragraph. Describe your company as if it belonged to another founder, and write what you'd tell that founder. Then ask one person who sees your blind spots to read it and tell you what you missed. When they do, pause before you answer.

If you work around one: write down three results you drove this year, with numbers, and one decision you'd like to own outright. Bring the decision, not a list of complaints, to your next 1:1.

That's where it starts.

Frequently asked questions

What is an "aha moment" for a CEO? It's the point where a leader recognizes, in his or her own words, that they're the one holding the company in place. Real change usually follows, because the conclusion is theirs.

How does a CEO get to the aha? Step into the conversations that make you uncomfortable, keep people close who can see your blind spots and be open enough to pause and consider what they say instead of defending yourself.

Can I make my CEO have the aha? No. You can make it more likely by framing conversations around ownership, naming deflection calmly once and asking the mirror question. The conclusion has to be his.

What if he's heard it all before and nothing changes? Believe the pattern. Keep a factual record, build your own proof points and relationships and set your own timeline for whether to stay.

Bring this conversation to your leaders

I speak to CEOs, founders and leadership teams about building companies that don't run through one person. If your leaders are working on ownership at every level, invite Nik to speak.

Get The Altitude Report. One clear idea you can act on by Monday. Sign up.

Clarity Changes Altitude. And Altitude Changes Outcomes.™

Share this paperLinkedInXFacebookEmail

Newsletter

Get each paper first.

Sign up for The Altitude Report and you'll hear when each white paper is ready.

See our SMS Terms, Privacy Policy and Terms of Use